ía habitual en la climatización de los hogares tanto en aires de tipo splits conductos! Plain radiography of the abdomen may reveal radiopaque gallstones, but will not reveal radiolucent stones or biliary dilatation? 50 augmentin quanto costa slily
µl of the cell suspensions are added to each well of microtiter plates? Temporary hyper or hypopigmentation has been reported with repeated application of RETIN-A! The third study examined longer-term effects in 121 participants with documented nonorganic insomnia [ 15]. This interference with reuptake of norepinephrine and/or serotonin is believed by some to underlie the antidepressant activity of amitriptyline? En effet l’action du cialis soft tabs à commencer à se manifester 20 après la prise pour une longue durée! These provisions and other civil rights laws are enforced by a number of federal agencies, including the Department of Justice (DOJ), the Department of Education (ED), the Department of Labor, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the Department of Health and Human Services, and others!
I optimally elocon cream uk
am allegeric to oral antibotics, is there a topical antibotic that you would reccomend. Non oltrepassa invece la barriera emato-encefalica. This information is purely for educational purposes only. En la lista que se presenta a continuación se ha clasificado a los microorganismos de acuerdo con su sensibilidad in vitro frente a Augmentin? Nicht selten strahlt ein solches Problem auch auf Ihre Beziehung und Partnerschaft aus, tretiva 20 mg benefits
da ein intaktes Intimleben einfach dazugehört und stattfinden sollte. La bromelina aumenta la absorción de la amoxicilina?
tretiva 25 benefits
tretiva 10 side effects
what is tretiva used for
sotret vs tretiva
tretiva 25 mg price
Ork out well for me?
W przypadku jednak, tretiva 5mg price
gdy leczenie jest konieczne, należy poprosić o poradę lekarza. 1186a(c)(4); and alien registration and fingerprint records, inj kenacort price dispiritedly
tretiva 10 mg benefits in hindi
tretiva 30 hindi
tretiva 30 mg side effects
tretiva capsules for acne
tretiva 20 tablet in hindi
how tretiva works
Unfortunately, editorially cialis kaufen paypal
however, there is not a good way to tell that the eosinophile is degranulating in response to the fungus by methods that most physicians can use!
Tretiva tablet 20mg
It can be made up by Anazao pharmaceuticals, tretiva 10 for acne Sinucare or JCB labs. The Content on this Site is presented in a summary fashion, and is intended to be used for educational and entertainment purposes only! The kamagra gold canada athwart
term was very fitting, because a chemise is basically a very long shirt, or today would look like a woman’s slip? For example, some health conditions may cause loss of appetite, which can lead to weight loss? Выводится исключительно почками в неизмененном виде, признаков метаболизма у человека не обнаружено!
tretiva tablet price
tretiva 30 mg price
tab tretiva 5 mg
tretiva 30 benefits in hindi
tretiva 25 tablet
tretiva 40 price
In these patients, tretiva 20 hindi physicians should suspect inappropriate antibiotic therapy or a lung complication, such as an empyema or abscess! A recent biopsy performed during upper endoscopy identified Barrett's esophagus. Większość działań niepożądanych propranololu ma charakter łagodny i przejściowy! L’un d’eux raconte que la dysfonction érectile est toujours une conséquence du stress et de problèmes psychologiques chez des hommes? • Thevis, tretiva 5mg price M; Kuuranne, T; Walpurgis, K; Gever, H.
tretiva capsule 10 mg
cap tretiva 30 mg
tretiva 10 benefits
tretiva 5 mg reviews
tretiva 10 price
tretiva mg tablet
tretiva tablet price
"Women have waited long enough," write Even The Score, of their pro-flibanserin petition, which is reported to have attracted more than 40,000 signatures? For migraine prophylaxis, kamagra price edictally
doses up to 120 mg/day PO have been used? Methamphetamine: (Moderate) Sympathomimetic agents and adrenergic agonists tend to increase blood glucose concentrations when administered systemically! Patients present with a variety of symptoms, including urinary obstruction, fever, myalgias, decreased libido or impotence, painful ejaculation and low-back and perineal pain. Botulinum toxin acts through presynaptic inhibition of acetylcholine release at the neuromuscular junction? With stress exercise, tretiva 30 benefits
21 CFS patients (241%) demonstrated ACWM. As of 2009, tretiva 5mg price nearly 6,960,000 children were receiving services under the IDEA. For most people, tretiva 20 uses in hindi
this is the first time they’ve ever heard of Meldonium? Follow the teeth will grant our patients with a protocol! Such misuse has been created by doctors prescribing antibiotics for colds which are caused by viruses, not bacteria? One perspective states brand equity cannot be negative, tretiva 5mg price
hypothesizing only positive brand equity is created by marketing activities such as advertising, PR, and promotion? Nous acceptons tout avis positif tout comme négatif car c'est cela qui nous permet de nous améliorer afin de vous offrir le meilleur service possible! (Blood samples will also be tested for HLA type in order to do immunologic studies in the laboratory? Two upper heart chambers called the right and left atria (each is called an atrium) receive blood that returns to the heart from the body. Biofilms are highly structured communities of microorganisms that attach to one another and to surfaces! Não se espera que estes efeitos sobre o metabólito tenham consequências clínicas? *Please glucophage price first-hand
note: this Portal is intended ONLY for drug manufacturers/applicants? If I die from car crash, ventolin come si usa ulteriorly
I would have a fear of the roads and cars for the rest of my life? La transformación clave, tretiva 5mg price
que luego se mantuvo en muchos beta bloqueadores desarrollados con posterioridad, consistió en introducir un puente metoxi en la estructura ariletanolamina del pronetalol, incrementando notablemente la potencia del compuesto! Penicillins acylate the penicillin-sensitive transpeptidase C-terminal domain by opening the lactam ring! In studies, women who took the drug reported just one “extra sexually satisfying event” per month, and the FDA recommends you stop taking the “female Viagra” after eight weeks if you see no improvement! In addition long-term effectiveness needs to be studied in RCTs in patients taking such drugs over at least one year, tretiva medicine used for
either daily or intermittently! Eight laboratories analysed known control and fortified milk sample for 7 tetracyclines including chlortetracycline, oxytetracycline and tetracycline! A lot of the interactions are ones where one of the drugs will not work as well as it should! Specifically, tretiva 25 mg serotonin modulators may enhance dopamine blockade, possibly increasing the risk for neuroleptic malignant syndrome? Both these product were eaten not to save me from starvation but exclusively for the purpose to improve some my physical abilities? Zovirax penally uroxatral price in usa
regularly, particularly in patients that have tested positive for HIV?
Tretiva 40 mg
Można też kupić perfumy z feromonami lub taki preparat http://wwwlibidocompl/aff/sknery Z tego co rozmawiałem z kobietami, tretiva 5mg price
to pomaga! 1 , differin gel uk amazon skippingly
15 Hospitalization is required for all infants from birth to 20 days of age, infants three weeks to three months of age with fever, and all children who appear toxic! Siendo la vida media de eliminación de 3 a 6 horas? 10 parlodel canada impotently
Lovett SM, Weiss JD, Diogo MJ, Williams PT, and Garite TJ! If you are having a similar problems just email him on (okhueleigbespellhome@outlookcom)! Recommends focusing on a different set of viruses, cap tretiva 10mg called enteroviruses? Prescribers or other health professionals should inform patients, their families, and their caregivers about the benefits and risks associated with treatment with amitriptyline hydrochloride and should counsel them in its appropriate use!
tretiva 10 for acne
tretiva 25 mg price
tretiva 10 uses
Japanese researchers experimented on rats with elevated lipid and triglyceride levels caused by liver tumors! The ICCRN trial aimed to discover whether early treatment with amitriptyline could give patients a better chance at getting IC under control and to see if it might be the best first treatment? Tumuric with yogurt and olive and a splash of lime. At Survivor Series, tretiva benefits
McMahon defeated Undertaker in a Buried Alive match with help from Kane? Long history of use in Brazilian folk medicine as an aphrodisiac! Recall it later, and the brain retraces the original memory’s route, further solidifying it! To create a transcriptional regulator fusion protein of the invention, a nucleic acid encoding a mutated Tet repressor is then ligated in-frame to another nucleic acid encoding a transcriptional activation domain and the fusion construct is incorporated into a recombinant expression vector! You will not receive a so-called "shelf CC", shallaki capsules price ceaselessly
but a new entity with a clear tax, history and ownership record that truly belongs to you from day one!
VR tools for 3D asset creation and scene management purposes are emerging in greater numbers
than ever before, encouraged by the growing use of VR technology. The adoption rate of these VR tools is an indirect indicator of VR interfaces’ benefits, which are not clear when compared to traditional interfaces.
The potential of VR interfaces is nicely illustrated by Bruce Branit’s “World Builder” short film from 2009, which depicts a fictional VR tool for creating 3D worlds:
Such VR interfaces have a lot of promise for fun and intuitive creation and editing of digital assets. But can they match or surpass the productivity achieved with traditional interfaces that utilize a pointing device and a keyboard? This is a question that has been on my mind throughout my VR research career.
Unfortunately there is little research about the immersive VR interfaces’ advantages over traditional interfaces. This hasn’t stopped companies from adding VR interfaces to their existing software, or creating new VR applications for tasks that in the past have been mainly performed using more traditional input devices.
Oculus Medium is an example of the latter. Basically it is Zbrush
in VR: a sculpting application for creating 3D models. Unlike Medium, conventional sculpting applications like Zbrush and Mudbox rely on traditional interfaces, and are heavily used in a professional capacity.
VR editors in game engines are another example of using VR interfaces for existing tasks. 3D asset creation and management functionality has been recently added to Unreal Engine and Unity. Below video demonstrates Unreal Engine’s VR editor:
Similar VR editor for scene management is available also for Unity. The Unreal and Unity VR editors are intended to be used via motion controllers, and both include 3D widgets and basic 3D interaction techniques such as navigation, as well as creating and manipulating objects.
For now, Unreal VR editor seems to be slightly more advanced, as it contains snapping, mesh editing tools, and the ability to paint textures on mesh objects. I have personally experimented with such features in the past, by creating an immersive 3D user interface for Blender.
So far I don’t see anything in the aforementioned VR editors, which couldn’t be done with a more traditional graphical user interface, which is also likely to be more productive. In the context of game development suites and 3D animation & modeling, I can imagine VR interfaces being faster only in tasks that do not require great accuracy: quick and dirty placement of objects, 3D sculpting, and animation blocking. More intelligent snapping tools could help this situation in the future.
In the below table I compare VR interfaces to traditional graphical user interfaces that rely on a pointing device (usually mouse) and a keyboard.
pointing device & keyboard interfaces
+ better spatial perception
+ better pointer accuracy
+ increased physical activity
+ less fatigue and strain
+ potentially more intuitive
+ more ergonomic
+ potentially more fun
+ more efficient/productive
VR headsets offer 3D stereo and head tracking. These features provide better spatial perception when compared to 2D displays. There is plenty of research
that supports this notion. VR interfaces also have the potential to be more intuitive or even more fun than traditional interfaces, since they are better suited for mimicking real world interaction. Furthermore, VR interfaces are more suitable for exergaming purposes.
On the other hand, 2D mice have better pointer accuracy and ergonomics than VR controllers, because the user hand rests on a table and motion is restricted to a 2D plane. Current VR controllers are often held in mid-air, which elicits fatigue and strain.
More accurate pointing allows faster object selection using a smaller motion range, which helps traditional interfaces to be more efficient. Another factor contributing to the efficiency of traditional interfaces, is the use of keyboard. A keyboard has dozens of buttons that can all be mapped to different actions. Conversely, VR controllers have only a few buttons and much fewer button press combinations.
If you have any doubts about current VR interfaces being less productive in the terms of performed tasks, then I invite you to observe a professional 3D modeler or a professional gamer using a traditional input devices:
Researchers have created and will continue to create studies that compare task performance (e.g. 3d modeling tasks) between traditional interfaces and VR interfaces. Ultimately it is the adoption rate of VR interfaces by professionals that determines their usefulness compared to traditional interfaces.
Therefore we ought to observe if and at what capacity professionals use VR interfaces in applications like Unity, Unreal, and Medium.
Will professional 3D artists start to prefer something like Oculus Medium over Zbrush or Mudbox? Only time will tell. I reckon that there are certain tasks where the use of VR interfaces could become popular (EDIT: for example creating the overall base mesh with a VR tool, while doing detailed sculpting and retopo with traditional tools), whereas majority of work in Unreal, Unity, and 3D animation & modeling software will remain to be performed with traditional input devices. Mouse and keyboard are here to stay for the foreseeable future.
There are no guarantees that VR interfaces would be rapidly adopted by professionals in a domain like 3D modeling; plenty of work still remains to be done in the design, software, and hardware aspects of VR interfaces.
In this article I have used the term “traditional interfaces” as an abbreviation for graphical user interfaces that utilize a 2D monitor, pointing device, and keyboard. I avoided using the term WIMP (windows, icons, menus, pointer) interfaces, because its definition is unclear about the inclusion of keyboard shortcuts.
Similarly, I used the term “VR interface” to mean 3D user interfaces that utilize an immersive display (head-mounted display or CAVE) and 3D input devices. Since my points also apply to augmented reality – a subset of mixed reality (MR)
– I could have replaced “VR interfaces” with the term “MR interfaces”, if we consider VR to be a subset of MR. The latter notion is slightly misleading, because MR was originally defined as “…anywhere between the extrema of the virtuality continuum.” In other words, VR aims to provide completely artificial reality and not a mix of real and artificial.
Recently, a new term called “extended reality”
(XR) has emerged, which is intended to cover the whole reality-virtuality continuum. When it comes to including VR under the XR umbrella, it’s debatable whether extending reality with artificial is any more appropriate than mixing the two. In summary, practitioners could benefit if user interface terminology was more refined.
There was a bug in one of the newly added scripts that made the head & HMD direction matching (and yaw drift correction) work only half of the time. The bug can be fixed by replacing line 124 in RUISYawDriftCorrector.cs from driftVector = Quaternion.Euler(0, -Vector3.Angle(driftingForward, driftlessForward), 0) * Vector3.forward; to driftVector = Quaternion.Euler(0, ((Vector3.Cross(driftingForward, driftlessForward).y < 0)?-1:1) * Vector3.Angle(driftingForward, driftlessForward), 0) * Vector3.forward;
Please note that for now this is an unofficial release, and the Download page still links to the old RUIS 1.10 file, which doesn't have Perception Neuron support. A new, official RUIS release will come out later this year.
The project contains a new example scene (RUISViveNeuron), which allows you to use Perception Neuron with HTC Vive. It has some nice features like automatic yaw drift correction. Furthermore, you can also use Kinect and other sensors together with the Perception Neuron, as long as Vive is set as the "master coordinate system".
Check out the READMENeuronTest.txt file that comes with the project for more details.
Update regarding RUIS Forum
I also want to thank Dev for pointing out a problem with the RUIS Forum
registration, which I have now fixed. Consequently, the forum registration works again!
A new version of RUIS is available at our download page. It finally adds support for Oculus Rift CV1 and HTC Vive, while requiring Unity 5.4. All head-mounted displays and motion controllers (including Oculus Touch) that support OpenVR can now be used in RUIS. They can also be calibrated to operate in the same coordinate system with Kinect.
Choices for calibrating device pairs
A good example of using Kinect body-tracking together with a head-mounted display in the same coordinate system is demonstrated by our Vertigo demo (which now also supports HTC Vive):
This is the first time since the Oculus Rift DK1 and its extended mode that it is again possible with RUIS for Unity to render simultaneously to a head-mounted display and other displays, including CAVE setups:
4-wall CAVE test (panorama)
If you’re rendering on other displays besides head-mounted displays in RUIS, you should be aware that Unity has a bug with custom projection matrices, which messes up shadows. Unity 5.5 will apparently get rid of the bug. Until then, there is a quick fix
See the latest RUIS readme
for more information about this release.
The next version of RUIS for Unity will include a simple OpenVR calibration process that allows you to match the coordinate systems of an OpenVR device and a custom tracking system of your choice (e.g. OptiTrack mocap setup). My aim is to enable developers to easily use head-mounted displays with their own (possibly high-end) full-body mocap systems, thus enabling simplified development of first-person avatar experiences.
I recently gave a talk titled “Staying Ahead of the Curve in Virtual Reality” at ARTtech Seminar of Assembly computer festival
(video embedded at the end of this post). In the talk I discussed some of my own work, and gave an overview on current consumer VR and its near future. In this post I want to focus on the following three considerations for VR developers that I laid out in the finale of the talk:
1. Justification for VR
Ask yourself, why does your application need to utilize VR? Are you using VR just as a gimmick? Games and other applications do not get magically better just by converting them into VR. The use of VR is a no-brainer in certain types of games and entertainment where additional immersion and depth cues are important. But that is not the case for all games (2D games being the most obvious ones), let alone business software.
Take into account that currently the added immersion of head-mounted displays come at the cost of ergonomics; the user has to wear a heavy, sweaty headset that induces vergence-accommodation conflict
and suffers from a low resolution. Over time all these issues will be alleviated and even removed altogether, but people will still be using 2D displays far into the foreseeable future. The added value from the use of VR must outweigh its costs for your application.
Furthermore, VR interfaces and traditional interfaces excel at different tasks (I’ll discuss that in a future post), and it is not clear yet in which application domains the use of VR brings noticeable benefits. Entertainment and training VR applications seem like safe bets. But the net benefits are less clear for other domains. For example, in the domain of 3D content creation we can pose the following question: which of the numerous real-world 3D modeling and animation tasks faced daily by production companies become more efficient in VR? Further experimentation is needed from researchers and practitioners of VR.
2. Social VR
I encourage VR developers to give thought on how they could benefit from having people interact together within their VR application. Mere head and controller tracking adds a good amount of expressive power to non-verbal communication in VR. A glimpse of this can be seen at the end of the Oculus Toybox demo video. Humans are social by nature, and all the major consumer VR companies are looking into bringing more human expressions into VR. Thus, in the future consumer VR tracking systems will track our whole bodies, eyes, and facial expressions.
At one end of the social VR spectrum is the concept of metaverse, along with massive online virtual worlds and social networks. AltspaceVR
are examples of early attempts at creating immersive, online virtual worlds. At the moment they are still relatively small scale and could be described as VR playgrounds for multiple users. In contrast to open virtual worlds and VR town squares, there will also be demand for more intimate telepresence applications for two people or small groups to convene. Such applications could be a part of a larger metaverse or made available as a standalone, single-purpose app like Skype.
VR game developers should consider adding social dimensions to their games, even for single-player experiences. Simplest way to do this is to implement spectator modes and live VR streaming. A company called Vreal
is developing a software platform for that purpose, with the aim of becoming the Twitch of VR.
Multiplayer games that involve waiting (e.g. for the start of the next match) could include simple VR waiting rooms for social interaction. As online communities tend to be riddled with abuse, you shoul look into ways of reducing such bad behavior.
And lets not forget the possibilities that online collaboration in VR presents for business software, as demonstrated by MiddleVR‘s Improov3 demo:
3. Augmented Virtuality / Multitasking
Many current consumer VR headsets completely block the view to the real world, requiring the user’s full attention. If you’re a VR game developer, ask yourself whether your game is captivating enough to keep players away from other activities. Because when the player gets bored, the only escape is to remove the headset and quit the game.
All games become repetitive sooner or later, when the player gets used to the gameplay mechanic or is forced to do mindless grinding in order to proceed. Nevertheless, many players keep playing because they want to see what the game has to offer around the next corner. In non-VR games the players can cope with the boredom by simultaneously engaging some additional activity.
According to a study by Foehr (2006), American teenagers frequently consumed another media while playing video games;
41% of the total time spent on video games involved such multitasking. Playing video games was most commonly paired with watching TV and listening to music. Due to the reality-occluding nature of head-mounted displays, VR developers need to see extra effort to provide similar multitasking capacities that are implicitly present in non-VR games.
HTC and Valve were smart to allow some real-world multitasking by equipping the Vive headset with a camera. This augmented virtuality
implementation allows the user to utilize their keyboard and grab their drink while wearing the headset.
Fortunately VR can be augmented with anything, and we are not limited only to real world elements. Envelop VR (EDIT: they folded, check outa company called Vinstead) and Virtual Desktop
applications already demonstrate how to use 2D applications in VR. But rather than have a VR desktop application, I’m more enthusiastic about bringing arbitrary 2D content and software streams inside any VR application or game. This will allow the user to seamlessly multitask between the 2D streams and the actual VR application where they appear. I created the below concept image using a screenshot from Pool Nation VR to illustrate this idea:
In this example the player has augmented the game with two additional 2D streams positioned in the virtual world: a Reddit browser tab and an episode of The Office (streaming from a hard-drive or online video service such as Netflix). Both streams could be viewed and interacted with while playing virtual pool.
VR developers could allow user-specified 2D streams into their application: video screens, browser tabs, and 2D applications. This is somewhat analogous to custom radio stations of GTA games, which allowed players to listen to their own music while playing. Of course it doesn’t make sense for every developer to implement their own 2D stream functionality, and a Unity/Unreal plugin with those capabilities will emerge in the near future.
To summarize this section: a VR developer should decide if their application allows “in-app multitasking” or requires full attention from users.
The latter approach could be too much to ask as far as games are concerned.
There are a number of compelling reasons about why now is a good time to start working with virtual reality (VR). Most of these points apply to augmented and mixed reality as well.
I start off by introducing my two main assertions regarding the current situation of consumer VR:
1. Anyone can become a VR pioneer.
Consumer VR is being invented right now, and VR as a media is being defined. VR research has been conducted for decades and in that regard experienced VR researchers have an advantage over hobbyists. But the spread of consumer VR hardware leads to democratization of this new media; now the masses can also have access to high-performance VR equipment. This situation can be compared to the arrival of home video cameras, which gave rise to influential film makers such as Stephen Spielberg.
2. Individuals and small teams can make a big impact in VR.
Many areas of consumer VR are uncharted territory, and in that sense independent developers and big companies are on the same level. Both can make major contributions in the field. You could for example get lucky and create a killer application for VR; think of Minecraft, Kerbal Space Program, and other small projects that came to be very influential. Not all discoveries and innovations need an enormous budget and a large team of engineers. A few years from now it will be more difficult to influence the field of VR as it becomes more established. *
This ongoing pioneering phase of consumer VR offers numerous opportunities for developers and creatives:
Finding application domains and niches where the use of VR is advantageous.
Developing tools for VR content production and distribution, e.g. the photoshops and wordpresses of VR.
Pioneering VR content fundamentals, such as effective VR storytelling techniques.
Creating better 3D user interfaces for VR and helping to define related standards.
Engineering hardware innovations.
Some of these opportunities will have big monetary rewards, and some have important consequences for the future of human culture and the way we interact with computers.
The hype surrounding VR is currently helping developers, and makes it easier to pitch your ideas. But be aware of the inflated expectations that will inevitably lead to a backlash of some magnitude. Furthermore, a mass adoption of consumer VR devices takes several years. So prepare for the long haul. Unity co-founder David Helgason suggested that new VR companies should have funding for the next 2-4 years.
Most developers in the Western world will target the English speaking market. However, one should not underestimate the Chinese VR market, and the possibilities that it offers. For example, gaming cafes are very popular in China, and they are gradually equipped with VR devices.
And finally, lets not forget that VR is fun and the technology provides countless ways to express yourself, both artistically and experimentally. If you want to get involved with VR development, but don’t know where to start, these answers on Quora will point you in the right direction.
* Assertion 2. relates to user-led innovation, which is a concept where not only big producer companies are a source of product innovation, but also individual users (including small companies) and communities. In my PhD thesis
I discuss VR also from a user-led innovation perspective (Section 2.3), while the main focus of the thesis is in VR application development. One example of current user-led innovation in the field of VR is the abundant experimentation with different forms of VR locomotion:
In May I had the opportunity to try out Microsoft Hololens. It had a phenomenal inside-out positional tracking, which felt very robust. As reported widely online, its field of view is very limited. That is the single biggest obstacle for usability and immersion. As a self-contained wearable display device, Hololens is a great “development kit” for augmented reality developers to start experimenting with the technology. I believe that it will be useful in a number of real-world cases, despite the narrow field of view.
I was surprised that the interactive cursor was locked to the center of the display, and could only be moved only by rotating my head. I was expecting to be able to relocate the cursor by moving my hand in front of the device, because hand gestures are also used for “clicking” and bringing up the menu. Hololens also comes with a wireless clicker peripheral that can be used instead of the gestures. That would be my preferred way for interaction due to the clicker being more robust and ergonomic. Perhaps the “locked” cursor is a good idea after all, for those same reasons.
Coming RUIS for Unity Update
A few words about the future update of RUIS for Unity: The currently distributed version 1.082 still requires Oculus Runtime 1.06, which is obsolete and does not support Oculus Rift CV1. I have created a beta version of RUIS that supports HTC Vive, which I used for adding Vive support for the Vertigo experience. I have not made that version public, because it is still very much a hack. I’m waiting for Unity to release stable version of Unity 5.4, which eases my job by adding native support to Vive and unifies the head-mounted display interface.
I have submitted my PhD thesis (about virtual reality) for review, but I still have a bunch of other projects I’m working on. Therefore the new RUIS version will probably come out in July or August. It’s worth the wait 🙂
I was going through my old photos and found something that I should have blogged years ago.
You see, I met the ”Godmother of Virtual Reality” Nonny de la Peña
at IEEE VR2013 conference, and we talked about her work. At that point I had already heard about her Guantanamo Bay detainee VR experience, where the user has to endure in a stress position while hearing “interrogation noises” from the next room.
What a way to put yourself in another person’s shoes! And that is the idea of immersive journalism, a concept coined by de la Peña. You could watch the news from a small box in your room, or you could experience the news in first person with the aid of virtual reality.
I liked Nonny’s ideas and asked to see more of her work. She was very hospitable and in March 2013 she gave me and my friend a tour at the USC Institute for Creative Technologies (ICT) in Los Angeles.
First Nonny showed us her production Hunger in LA. It’s an immersive journalism piece where the driving force is real audio recorded at Los Angeles food bank. At the time of the recording there were delays in food distribution, it started to get crowded, one person had a seizure, and ambulance had to be called.
Nonny described that some viewers of Hunger in LA had been so touched by the experience that they cried. This didn’t happen with me, or my friend who was a VR novice. Perhaps we were all too jaded for that. But the use of real, non-acted audio was very moving, and I can see how people could have strong reactions for such authentic content.
There were all sorts of set pieces in the ICT laboratory as seen in the background of the above photo. Apparently they have been working closely with US army, exploring military training applications of virtual reality.
We got to see different parts of the laboratory. Above is a lab desk full of prototypes at USC ICT, where Palmer Luckey worked as a lab technician with FOV2GO head-mounted display.
Oculus had given DK1s to ICT before the official shipping date of March 29th 2013.
This was one of the mobile head-mounted display prototypes that we tried.
We also got a chance to see ICT’s Light Stage, which has been used to capture 3D scans of actors for several movies. Many thanks to Nonny de la Peña for giving us the tour and sharing her work!
In November I got to borrow a HTC Vive dev kit for a few days. I was responsible for setting it up at a AEC hackathon in Helsinki. Before I share my experiences in detail, here are my two suggestions to Valve:
Allow developers to opt out from auto-updating SteamVR software. If I have a working demo configuration, I don’t want an automatic update to break it with a new plugin version etc.
Do not require Steam to run in the background of SteamVR. This is just common cleanliness, as it was a bit annoying that every time I started SteamVR it also launched Steam.
Overall the experience, particularly running the demos, was great. I already had tried the Aperture Robot Repair demo
in August, but the display quality and tracking accuracy still made me very happy. I got very positive reactions from my colleagues in Aalto University to whom I showed the Vive for the first time.
Getting the dev kit to work took awhile. After connecting and placing the physical hardware, SteamVR wasn’t able to properly access the hardware no matter what I tried. And there were plenty of things to try, as can be seen in the SteamVR forum. It wasn’t until I updated the firmware for the HMD and the controllers that everything started working. I had to use rather unwieldy command line tools, whereas Oculus Rift DK2 had offered a simple firmware update process through the Oculus Configuration Utility.
When all the systems showed green status in SteamVR, creating and running a test VR scene in Unity Editor was a breeze. As a side note I’m happy to see that Unity is integrating VR functionality directly into their engine, which eases development for different VR platforms. I’d imagine that Epic is doing the same with Unreal Engine.
Occasionally the Vive stopped working after restarting my computer, and I needed to uninstall Vive’s USB drivers and reboot to solve the problem. According to Valve this issue is related to Vive’s HMD control box. From what I understand the vast majority of problems reported in SteamVR forum can be attributed to that. I believe that the situation will be much better with the 2nd Vive dev kit.
I didn’t have any problems with the tracking quality and everything ran smoothly. My only grievance is that I couldn’t install any of the cool Vive demos from Steam. Currently Valve has to separately set those privileges for each Steam account, and we couldn’t get them to do that in the short time-frame that we had. Instead I resorted to googling for unofficial, 3rd party Vive demos, which understandably had lower production values. For some reason I needed to run each demo in administrator mode to get them to work.
To summarize: this first HTC Vive dev kit, its hardware and parts of the software, feels like it was hacked together by a group of scientists in a lab. What actually happened is perhaps very close to that. In contrast Oculus DK1 and DK2 were slightly more polished, because as a pioneer Oculus had more to prove. This is not a complaint, and I’m quite happy that HTC and Valve decided to grant developers such an early access. HTC Vive, particularly its Lighthouse tracking, is just so good that it’s easy to overlook the lack of refinement in this early dev kit. I hope that soon I will get a permanent access to HTC Vive, so I can integrate it into my RUIS toolkit, enabling developers to combine room-scale Lighthouse tracking with full-body tracking of Kinect.
by researchers from The University of Louisiana at Lafayette reviews RUIS among with two other virtual reality toolkits for Unity. RUIS did very well in the review, and the original version of the article that I read in August stated that
with RUIS being free and highly versatile, it is the clear winner for low budget applications.
The author changed the wording in the final article version to “promising for low budget applications“, because their adviser suggested using a wording that sounds less biased. Oh well 🙂
In the article RUIS reached almost the same score as MiddleVR (a professional $3000 toolkit) which came on top when price was not considered, as seen from the below table adapted from the article:
Performance & reliability
CAVE display flexibility
Ease of use
In the above table each category was given 1-5 points.
In terms of “Documentation and support” getReal3D scored 10, MiddleVR 20, and RUIS 14. Improving RUIS documentation and providing tutorials is in our todo list.
The article is slightly mistaken in that it says that top and bottom CAVE displays are not supported by RUIS, but this is not the case. The display wall center position, normal, and up vectors just need to be configured in RUISDisplay component. Please note that RUIS is mostly intended for CAVEs with a small number of displays because each view is rendered sequentially. For faster CAVE rendering in Unity you should probably try MiddleVR or getReal3D, which offer clustered rendering.
The article was published in International Journal for Innovation Education and Research (IJIR).
P.S. I participated in Burning Man 2015, where I demoed our Vertigo application
at VR Camp. They had a dozen of computers with Oculus Rift DK2 and a HTC Vive. Here is a photo of me trying out Tilt Brush on HTC Vive.